Skip to main content
Game Review

Settlers of Catan: A review by Noah N.

By January 24, 2024No Comments

Introduction

Catan, previously known as “The Settlers of Catan”, is a board game that involves strategy, trade, resource management, and territory building. I’ve heard that Catan is considered to be one of the most popular “gateway” to tabletop gaming since it’s easy to learn (ignoring the fact there’s 16 pages of instructions) and has a good mix of tactical depth and player interaction, and I would have to agree. I’m not much of a tabletop player (probably the most ‘tabletop’ interaction I have is playing Baldur’s Gate 3 with a group of friends since D&D is a little more involved than we’re ready for), but Catan was genuinely an enjoyable experience and I could see myself playing it again.

Materials and Setup

Catan’s main components include 19 hexagonal tiles that serve as terrain types to create the island of catan, related resources cards and number tokens to keep track, miniature pieces for settlements, cities, and roads, a stack of cards that serve as development cards which cost resources to play, a robber piece, and 2 die. Because the water pieces around the hexagonal tiles fit together, it makes setting up the game wrong basically impossible which is a nice feature. The replayability with the hexagonal tiles added with the uncertainty of what you’ll draw from the stack keeps the game fresh and ensures no 2 games are the same. Then, the dice roll for resource production and the ability to trade is a nice level of uncertainty that doesn’t feel impossible to overcome. 

Strategy and Balance

As stated earlier, Catan does a great job of not making the game feel too dependent on chance; it’s well balanced and rewards long-term strategic planning and adaptability while still including a satisfying blend of luck with the resource dice roll. Then, add the development cards and you have a game that provides the occasional element of surprise and multiple paths to victory (in this case, achieving 10 “victory points”). You’ll need to be able to plan ahead while staying on top of the immediate game state since things can change quickly, making every decision critical.

Player Interaction

I really like the player interaction in this game, namely the ability to trade resources with other players. The ability to negotiate (or reject trades if you want to play that way) adds a dynamic social element to the game (again, the game will be different every time you play with different people even because of this feature alone). I think it’s also a fun way to keep players engaged throughout the game, forming alliances and rivalries, and can heavily impact an opponent’s strategy. 

Conclusion

To end, Catan is a beginner-friendly tabletop game that I believe is widely accessible with its easy to learn rules, and deeply engaging with its unique mechanics. It has a good blend of strategy, resource management, luck, and player interaction that creates a unique and dynamic experience every time it’s played. While it can be luck-driven at times, your strategic choices and the ability to trade still provide an adequate sense of control and involvement. I think its title as a gateway to tabletop gaming is a great way to describe it (example: the first and only time I played was nearly 3 years ago and I still (mostly) remembered the rules going into this game session). And as someone who really loves the simplicity of Candy Land, I feel like that says a lot.